top of page

Supreme Court Ruling Ensures Transparency and Protects Rights in Arrests: NewsClick Founder's Case Sets Precedent

The Supreme Court of India's recent ruling in the case of Prabir Purkayastha, founder of the news platform NewsClick, has significant implications for future arrests in the country. The Court found Purkayastha's arrest and remand to be illegal due to the Delhi Police's failure to inform him of the grounds for arrest in writing. This decision serves as a critical reminder of the importance of upholding fundamental rights and adhering to proper legal procedures during arrest. 

The Case and Allegations 

Purkayastha was arrested in October 2023 on accusations of receiving illegal funding from China, allegedly routed through the US and intended to undermine India's national security. While the specifics of the case are under investigation, the Supreme Court's focus in this instance centered on the legality of the arrest procedure itself. 

Right to Information: A Cornerstone of Due Process 

The crux of the Court's judgment lies in the fundamental right of an arrested individual to be informed about the grounds of arrest. This right, enshrined in law, ensures that the accused is not left in the dark about the charges against them. Having access to this information is crucial for them to consult with legal counsel effectively and challenge the legality of their detention. 

Justice Sandeep Mehta, delivering the verdict, emphasized the importance of providing the grounds of arrest in writing. This written format allows the accused and their lawyer to analyze the details, prepare a defense, and potentially argue for bail. The lack of such information in Purkayastha's case rendered the arrest and remand process flawed, leading to his release on bail. 

Beyond Purkayastha: A Precedent for Upholding Legal Procedures 

The Supreme Court's ruling transcends the specifics of the NewsClick founder's case. It sets a strong precedent for future arrests across India. Here's how this decision is likely to impact law enforcement practices: 

  • Stricter Adherence to Legal Procedures: The judgment serves as a reminder to police forces nationwide that adhering to established procedures during an arrest is paramount. This includes informing the arrested individual, in writing, about the reasons for their detention. 

  • Empowering the Accused: By guaranteeing access to information about the grounds of arrest, the ruling empowers those taken into custody. They are now better equipped to understand their situation, exercise their right to legal representation, and potentially challenge the grounds for their detention. 

  • Protecting Fundamental Rights: The decision underscores the sanctity of the right to life and personal liberty as enshrined in the Indian Constitution (Articles 20, 21, and 22). Any violation of these fundamental rights will be viewed with seriousness by the judiciary. 

  • Clarification for UAPA Cases: This ruling clarifies that the right to be informed about the grounds of arrest applies not only to cases under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA) but also to those charged under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA). This is a significant point, as UAPA cases often involve sensitive national security concerns. 

Moving Forward: A More Balanced Approach to Arrests 

The Supreme Court's decision in the Purkayastha case strikes a crucial balance between ensuring national security and protecting individual rights. By mandating that police inform the arrested of the grounds of arrest in writing, the Court ensures transparency in the arrest process. This not only protects the rights of the accused but also strengthens public trust in law enforcement. 

While investigations and trials proceed to determine the truth behind the charges against Purkayastha, the Court's ruling has broader ramifications. It serves as a beacon for stricter adherence to legal procedures and a reminder of the importance of upholding fundamental rights in a democratic society. This judgment is likely to shape future arrests across India, ensuring a more balanced approach that prioritizes both national security and individual liberty. 


Follow Global Lawyers Association for more news and updated from International Legal Industry.




bottom of page